Draw the pentagram star with a ruler, then freehand the circle. Use chalk. Place the following BETWEEN each point of the pentagram, within the circle but outside the star - 1 cup homebrewed tea, 1 cup real seawater, 1 unlit candle, one secret written on a slip of paper and rolled up tight. Write down the sweetest gift the subject ever gave you in the center of the circle in chalk. Hope for a moment, then drink the tea. light the candle and burn the secret. Wash the rest away with seawater.
That’s…oddly fitting, and sweet. I do answer to tea. Thank you!
Also: This summon method results in me arriving bearing enough of the missing item, quality chocolate, to share.